OTK Boots Review – Sam Edelman / Carlos Santana

Sam Edelman Paloma Over The Knee Boots [More options HERE and HERE| sz 6 • Love Stitch Mock Sweater Dress | sz S Stretch Maroon Leggings  | sz S H&M Studded Belt | sz S

Just because winter is almost over doesn’t mean you can’t wear boots. This isn’t the same as the no white after Labor Day rule [which no one follows]. The OTK trend [Over The Knee] started when Julia Roberts donned these babies in Pretty Woman and it looks like it’s not going anywhere. As you may know, when I become obsessed with a piece I usually buy two or three of them in various colors and OTKs are no exception. I bought two similar but different boots by Sam Edelman and Carlos Santana [yes, the musician] and wanted to share my thoughts. 

Follow KeePieces. with Bloglovin 

SAM EDELMAN—PALOMA OTK

When I found these boots perusing Nordstrom Rack, I thought I struck gold! The moment I tried these on, I felt like Cinderella in her glass slippers [no exaggeration].

Details: It has a soft stretch suede [23 in. shaft, 8 in. calf circumference], flat heel [3/4 inch], bottom inner zipper, round toe, and toggle top tie. 

Sizing/Fit: I normally wear a size 5.5 in boots, but these are a size 6. The sizing was fine for me because I like to wear thick socks with boots and these had a narrower toe [get half a size up – if you don’t want your toes to feel squished]. Although it’s made of stretch suede, it was still loose on my legs. The toggle top is a nice feature to help with keeping the boots at thigh height. 

Quality: These boots usually run for $175 but got them for $100. They are currently on sale at Macy’s and SamEdelman.com. These are great quality boots and the suede is so soft! I also like the inner zipper so I can reach in and adjust my jeans [let’s be honest OTK boots makes them bunch up]. You get what you pay for with these boots and now that they’re on sale there’s no excuse not to get them. 

Follow KeePieces. with Bloglovin 

Carlos Santana Rumor Over The Knee Boot | sz 6 • Knit Scarf Military Wool Coat | sz 2 • J.Crew V-neck Sweater | sz XXS Joe’s Slim Ankle Jeans |  sz 0

Carlos by Carlos Santana—Rumor OTK

There I was minding my own business walking down the aisle and these jumped in front of me and said “BUY ME NOW”, how could I say no?

Details: These are faux stretch suede [21.5 in. shaft, 8 in. calf circumference], wrapped block heel [3.5 inch], bottom inner zipper, and round toe.

Sizing/Fit: I also bought these in a size 6. Again, it’s because I wear thick socks and hate the feeling of squished toes. These were snug around my legs and thigh more than the Sam Edelman [they weren’t tight – it just felt more “fitted”]. I really like how slim it was because it reminded me of the fit of the coveted Stuart Weitzman Highlander Boots. The block heel wasn’t excessively too tall, just perfect for a shorty like me. 

Quality: These boots usually run for $100 but got them for $40. They are currently on sale at Macy’s [plus 15% off with code PRES]. Although the suede isn’t as soft [well obviously, they’re faux, but no one can really tell] they’re comparable to the Sam Edelman OTKs and for cheaper. Even if these are more “fitted” I do have to readjust and pull them up [be realistic – what do you think would happen when you walk around in OTKs?]. The best part about these are the thick block heel which add to the height without the hurt.

Both of these boots are a deal especially if you’re shopping for OTKs to add to your closet collection [definitely a must-have staple piece!]. I hope my reviews helped – let me know which one [or both!] you get and how the fit is for you. 

Carlos Santana Rumor Over The Knee Boot | sz 6 • Knit Scarf Military Wool Coat | sz 2 • J.Crew V-neck Sweater | sz XXS Joe’s Slim Ankle Jeans |  sz 0

Follow KeePieces. with Bloglovin

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply